Information Processing, Computation, and Cognition
In a new paper by Andrea Scarantino and me, we outline the relations between cognition and (different notions of) computation and information processing, as well as the relations between the different notions of computation and information processing. To my knowledge, this has not been done before (except in an earlier, less sophisticated paper by the same authors).
Here is the abstract of our paper:
Computation and information processing are perhaps the most fundamental notions in cognitive science. They are also among the most imprecisely discussed. Many cognitive scientists take it for granted that cognition involves computation, information processing, or both. Many write as if computation and information processing were the same thing. In addition, different cognitive scientists mean different things by ‘computation’ and ‘information processing’. To help improve on this situation, which leads to a great amount of talking at cross purposes, we outline a taxonomy of notions of computation and information processing and analyze how different notions of computation relate to different notions of information processing. We argue that cognition involves information processing in several senses of the term, and as a consequence, that cognition is computation at least in a weak sense that we spell out. We hope this will bring greater clarity and precision to the debate over the nature of cognition.
We'd like to submit the paper as soon as feasible. If anybody is interested, comments would be very welcome.
Here is the abstract of our paper:
Computation and information processing are perhaps the most fundamental notions in cognitive science. They are also among the most imprecisely discussed. Many cognitive scientists take it for granted that cognition involves computation, information processing, or both. Many write as if computation and information processing were the same thing. In addition, different cognitive scientists mean different things by ‘computation’ and ‘information processing’. To help improve on this situation, which leads to a great amount of talking at cross purposes, we outline a taxonomy of notions of computation and information processing and analyze how different notions of computation relate to different notions of information processing. We argue that cognition involves information processing in several senses of the term, and as a consequence, that cognition is computation at least in a weak sense that we spell out. We hope this will bring greater clarity and precision to the debate over the nature of cognition.
We'd like to submit the paper as soon as feasible. If anybody is interested, comments would be very welcome.
Posted by gualtiero piccinini at 8/20/2009 3:56 PM 
Categories: Intentionality, Cognition, Computation and Logic
Tags: computation information processing cogntion
Categories: Intentionality, Cognition, Computation and Logic
Tags: computation information processing cogntion
Trackbacks
-
7/6/2010 12:56 PM
Brains wrote:
As I mentioned some time ago , Andrea Scarantino and I wrote a paper on the relationships between information processing, computation, and cognition. As far as I know, it is the broadest and most systematic discussion of this topic to date. It also includes the most general and (what I consider to be) best formulation of my "mechanistic account" of computation. The paper is now forthcoming in the Journal of Biological Physics. If anyone is interested, a preprint may be found /files/30451-28882/Information_Processing_Computation_and_Cognition_preprint.pdf">here. ... -
7/6/2010 12:58 PM
Brains wrote:
As I mentioned some time ago , Andrea Scarantino and I wrote a paper on the relationships between information processing, computation, and cognition. As far as I know, it is the broadest and most systematic discussion of this topic to date. It also includes the most general and (what I consider to be) best formulation of my "mechanistic account" of computation. The paper is now forthcoming in the Journal of Biological Physics. If anyone is interested, a preprint may be found /files/30451-28882/Information_Processing_Computation_and_Cognition_preprint.pdf">here. Once again, many thanks to all those who provided ...
Why not adhere to the information theory standard of entities and relations: count the entities and calculate the relations. This would make a remarkable fit with the 100 billion or so neurons in the brain and the locality of thoughts (Penfield). That is all we have imho.
Reply to this
Thanks a lot to the several people who sent me comments! (Anna-Mari Rusanen, Alex Morgan, Malcolm Dean, and Dan Ryder.) The paper is now revised and submitted.
Reply to this