Imageless Thought

The standard story about the demise of introspectionist psychology goes something like this:  Towards the beginning of the 20th Century, experimental psychologists relied on introspecting subjects to study the mind.  Members of one prominent school believed that each thought is reducible to sensory images (visual, auditory including verbal, proprioceptive, etc.).  Among …

A Note on Heterophenomenology

In comments to some previous posts, Marcin Milkowski raised a spirited defense of Dennett’s heterophenomenology (HF) as a correct methodology of data from first-person reports (about mental states).  Among other statements, he made the following:   “HF is not about inferring beliefs from verbal behavior in any setting.  It’s about …

Do Emotions Split into Different Natural Kinds?

In his 1997 book, What Emotions Really Are, Paul Griffiths argues that emotions split into three different natural kinds.  But in his PSA talk a few weeks ago, Andrea Scarantino (a student of Griffiths) said that Griffiths now thinks that emotions do not split in the way he envisioned in his …

Knobe on the Continuity between Science and Common Sense

Joshua Knobe was kind enough to write me as follows (reproduced with permission):I was happy to see that you wrote up a description of oursession [two weeks ago at the PSA Meeting], and I’m glad that you are bringing attention to these important questions about the relationship between common sense andscientific …

Back to Top